Methodology
Every agency gets a score from 0.0 to 10.0 built from 15 criteria. Each criterion is scored from what the agency's own public website states. If a term is not published, it scores 0. The same rules apply to all 219 agencies.
Formula
- Account & net-split control, 40% weight, 5 criteria
- Verifiable operational proof, 35% weight, 5 criteria
- Fee, niche & entity clarity, 25% weight, 5 criteria
Group A carries the most weight because it decides who controls the account and the money. Group B covers how the work is done and whether results can be checked. Group C covers fees, niche readiness and whether there is a legal entity to hold to the contract.
What counts as evidence
- Text on a public, human-readable page of the agency's own domain, captured on the check date. Each scored quote is stored with its source URL and a SHA-256 hash prefix of the captured page.
- Operating history (criterion 15) comes from public domain registration (RDAP) or the earliest Web Archive capture, never from a founding year the agency claims.
- Not counted: sales calls, private PDFs, DMs, social media posts, paid press releases, and claims on third-party review sites.
The 15 criteria
Account & net-split control (40%)
01Creator retains sole login, email & 2FA
Handing over primary email or two-factor authentication allows a hostile agency to lock a creator out of her own subscriber base.
- Full credit:
- Explicitly states creator keeps primary login, email, and 2FA codes, granting revocable team access.
- Partial credit:
- General account-ownership statement without 2FA or access-mechanism detail.
- Zero:
- Not published on any captured page.
Observed scores: 0 (140) · 5 (33) · 8 (1) · 10 (45)
02Platform payouts land directly in creator's bank
When OnlyFans pays the creator directly and the agency invoices afterward, the agency can never withhold creator earnings.
- Full credit:
- States platform payouts go directly to the creator's own bank account first.
- Partial credit:
- Shared escrow or partial payout routing disclosed.
- Zero:
- Not published on any captured page.
Observed scores: 0 (154) · 5 (9) · 8 (1) · 10 (55)
03Commission calculated on net (after 20% OF fee), not gross
OnlyFans deducts 20% first. Taking X% of gross equals taking 1.25x X% of net (a '35% gross' deal actually takes 43.75% of what reaches the bank).
- Full credit:
- Explicitly states revenue share is calculated on net earnings after the 20% OnlyFans fee.
- Partial credit:
- Publishes a commission percentage without specifying gross vs. net basis.
- Zero:
- Not published on any captured page.
Observed scores: 0 (162) · 5 (24) · 10 (33)
04Short written exit notice (14 to 30 days) & $0 exit penalty
Twelve-month minimum term clauses trap creators inside non-performing management deals with no penalty-free exit.
- Full credit:
- Written notice of 14 to 30 days with $0 termination penalty published.
- Partial credit:
- Flexible exit mentioned without exact notice days or fee terms.
- Zero:
- Not published on any captured page.
Observed scores: 0 (136) · 3 (3) · 5 (13) · 6 (58) · 10 (9)
05$0 post-exit tail commission & content licence ends at exit
Sunset or 'tail' clauses let agencies keep collecting percentages on existing fans months after work stops.
- Full credit:
- States $0 commission after notice ends and promotional content licence terminates on exit.
- Partial credit:
- States creator retains content IP, silent on post-exit commission.
- Zero:
- Not published on any captured page.
Observed scores: 0 (127) · 2 (41) · 5 (33) · 8 (9) · 10 (9)
Verifiable operational proof (35%)
06Dated multi-month net results & verification route
Static cropped graphics are easy to fabricate; multi-month net progressions, screen recordings, and live anonymized call checks are verifiable.
- Full credit:
- Dated multi-month net screenshots, screen recordings, and a live anonymized verification route.
- Partial credit:
- Screenshots or case study figures published without a verification route.
- Zero:
- Not published on any captured page.
Observed scores: 0 (143) · 3 (47) · 4 (3) · 6 (17) · 7 (2) · 10 (7)
07Human 24/7 chatting policy, persona sheet & boundary rules
Undisclosed AI bots and unscripted chatters trigger fan chargebacks, violate creator boundaries, and burn subscriber retention.
- Full credit:
- Discloses human 24/7 chatters, written creator hard-limits, and PPV pricing floors.
- Partial credit:
- Mentions 24/7 chatting without human-vs-AI or boundary controls.
- Zero:
- Not published on any captured page.
Observed scores: 0 (105) · 2 (3) · 5 (100) · 6 (1) · 10 (10)
08Multi-channel organic traffic operations disclosed
Agencies relying solely on paid shoutouts force creators to fund subscriber growth on top of paying revenue share.
- Full credit:
- Details concrete organic acquisition across Reddit, X, and Instagram/TikTok Reels with account-safety practices.
- Partial credit:
- Names social platforms generically without operational workflow.
- Zero:
- Not published on any captured page.
Observed scores: 3 (74) · 6 (76) · 7 (46) · 8 (1) · 9 (1) · 10 (21)
09Weekly written KPI reporting & sample breakdown
Written weekly reports tracking net PPV, subscription rebills, chargebacks, and link clicks prevent blind trust.
- Full credit:
- Publishes reporting cadence plus an explicit sample report structure.
- Partial credit:
- States regular reporting cadence without sample structure.
- Zero:
- Not published on any captured page.
Observed scores: 0 (133) · 3 (1) · 5 (23) · 6 (53) · 8 (3) · 10 (6)
10Public fee calculators or educational contract benchmarks
Agencies publishing transparent split math and pricing benchmarks educate creators before asking for a signature.
- Full credit:
- Publishes interactive ungated creator calculators or contract checkers.
- Partial credit:
- Publishes written fee and contract benchmark guides.
- Zero:
- Not published on any captured page.
Observed scores: 0 (163) · 5 (50) · 8 (1) · 10 (5)
Fee, niche & entity clarity (25%)
11$0 upfront, $0 monthly retainer & itemized scope
Setup fees and retainers let agencies profit even when a creator earns zero incremental revenue.
- Full credit:
- $0 upfront/retainer, itemized deliverables, and 'nothing extra billed without approval' stated.
- Partial credit:
- $0 upfront stated OR service list itemized.
- Zero:
- Not published on any captured page.
Observed scores: 0 (93) · 2 (1) · 5 (76) · 7 (1) · 9 (1) · 10 (47)
12Dedicated niche, trans & faceless creator infrastructure
Trans, faceless, alt, and cosplay creators lose revenue when placed on generic cis-default scripts and subreddit lists.
- Full credit:
- Operates dedicated niche or trans division with tailored persona scripts, pricing floors, or geo-blocking.
- Partial credit:
- Accepts diverse or faceless creators without dedicated division pages.
- Zero:
- Not published on any captured page.
Observed scores: 0 (212) · 5 (2) · 8 (1) · 10 (4)
13States clearly who should NOT sign
Honest agencies disqualify creators who lack filming time or fit instead of signing everyone who applies.
- Full credit:
- Names specific situations where a creator should stay solo and suggests an alternative.
- Partial credit:
- States minimum filming consistency expectations.
- Zero:
- Not published on any captured page.
Observed scores: 0 (180) · 5 (31) · 8 (1) · 9 (1) · 10 (6)
14Registered corporate entity & legal terms published
An anonymous Telegram handle or Gmail address gives a creator zero legal recourse in a contract dispute.
- Full credit:
- Corporate entity, jurisdiction, and working domain policies published on public legal pages.
- Partial credit:
- Country and legal pages published without corporate registry detail.
- Zero:
- Not published on any captured page.
Observed scores: 0 (141) · 2 (2) · 5 (49) · 10 (27)
15Verified operating history (RDAP / Web Archive)
Self-claimed founding years are routinely exaggerated; public domain RDAP and Wayback captures establish real operating age.
- Full credit:
- 5+ years verified in public domain/archive records (7 pts for 3–5 yrs; 4 pts for 1–3 yrs).
- Partial credit:
- 3 to 5 years verified public domain or archive record.
- Zero:
- Not published on any captured page.
Observed scores: 1 (37) · 4 (70) · 7 (102) · 10 (10)
Why some scores fall between bands
The full and partial bands are anchors at 10 and 5, and some criteria record values in between where a page meets part of a band. The observed values for every criterion are listed above, and each one is in the open dataset with its quote and source, so anyone can check them.
Limits
- The index measures published terms, not service quality or earnings outcomes.
- A website can say one thing and a contract another. Creators should always read the signed agreement.
- Pages change. Scores reflect the capture date shown on each profile (2026-11-19 for v2026.11).
Agencies that publish clearer terms can request a re-check through the right of reply. Every change is logged in the changelog.